Our writers test and research products independently. When you buy through a link on our site we may earn a commission but this never affects our product choices.
Best baking trays 2024: top non-stick, steel, enamel and glass bakeware
Whether you’re making mouth-watering macarons or rustling up a quick midweek dinner of chicken nuggets and chips, a baking tray is an essential utensil that no kitchen should be without.
By Lucy Cotterill | Last updated Feb 15, 2024
It may not be the most glamorous of cooking implements, yet the humble baking tray is the unsung hero of the kitchen. No baker – novice or pro – can be without this trusty workhorse, which comes into its own when you’re making anything from cookies and cupcakes to pastries and pizzas.
Easy to store and taking up very little space in your kitchen alongside your saucepans and kitchen scale, this multifunctional tool is a must-have, but there's an overwhelming choice of baking trays to choose from. To help you decide, we’ve rolled up our sleeves to sift through hundreds of options so that you don’t have to.
We’ve sought out tried-and-tested recommendations from Mumsnet users and scrutinised authentic online reviews to help you buy with confidence. Whether it’s edgeless, enamel, eco-friendly or easy to clean, we’ve weighed them all up to bring you our list of the best - helping you find a tray that brings excellent cooking results every single time.
Whether you’re baking batches of biscuits or roasting tasty veggies, you’re sure to find a reliable kitchen assistant among our selections. Here are the best baking trays and sheets that will step up when the heat is on.
Plus, for more Mumsnetter-approved products to add to your kitchen, we also have guides to the best chopping board and can openers.
Best baking trays 2024: at a glance
Best overall: Scoville Neverstick Baking Tray, £17
Best budget: Argos Home 3-Piece Baking Tray Set, £9
Best heavy-duty: Le Creuset Rectangular Baking Sheet, £30
Best non-stick: Circulon Momentum Square Baking Tray, £17
Best glass: Pyrex Baking Tray, £11
Best set: Tala High-Performance Set of 3 Baking Trays, £23
Most versatile: Mermaid Hard Anodised Baking Sheet, £30
Best enamel: ProCook Enamel Baking Tray, £11
Most stylish: Prestige x Nadiya Baking Tray Set of 2 Oven Trays, £23
Best dishwasher-safe baking tray: Lakeland Multi-Purpose Oven Tray, £13
Best supermarket baking tray: Sainsbury's Home Oven Tray Black Large, £10
1. Best overall baking tray: Scoville Neverstick Baking Tray
Price on writing: £17 | Buy now from Argos
Key specs
Maximum temperature: Oven safe to 230°C | Dishwasher safe: Yes | Material: Aluminium | Size 36.6 x 28cm | Guarantee: Lifetime guarantee
What we like
Excellent non-stick coating
Easy to clean
Robust and hard-wearing
Generous size
What we don’t like
Very shallow
What Mumsnet users say
“Scoville!! They are fantastic and don't break the bank. I've had mine three years and it's still going strong despite being used to death.” (Recommended by Mumsnet user Changenameobviousreasons)
“Another vote for Scoville, they’re magic! Not expensive either, we ended up with the whole range of products.” (Tried and tested by Mumsnet user AaronBurrSirr)
Our verdict
If you’re tired of leaving your baking trays to soak or find yourself forever scrubbing away baked-on food when tackling the washing up, it could be time to give your trays an upgrade.
The Scoville Neverstick Baking Tray certainly lives up to its name, coming highly recommended by Mumsnet users and online reviewers for its excellent non-stick capabilities. It’s not just the brand’s baking trays making waves on the forums either – they also feature on our best frying pan and wok pages.
With a substantial size of 35cm, there’s plenty of space to spread out your food, ensuring good heat distribution that cooks evenly up to temperatures as high as 230°C. We love the robust and hardwearing aluminium construction. However, a word of caution – this baking tray is quite shallow, so you’ll need to grip it carefully through oven gloves when removing it from the oven.
2. Best budget baking tray: Argos Home 3-Piece Baking Tray Set
Price on writing: £9 | Buy now from Argos
Key specs
Maximum temperature: Oven safe to 230°C | Dishwasher safe: Yes | Material: Steel | Size: Three included: 35cm, 32cm, 30cm | Guarantee: 12 months
What we like
Excellent value for money
The set includes trays in three different sizes
Trays stack into each other for convenience and simple storage
What we don’t like
Some reviewers found the trays warped at high temperatures
Our verdict
This affordable trio of non-stick baking trays is an excellent choice for those who are on a more limited budget, also making a great starter set for those heading off to university or flying the nest. Including three trays in a variety of sizes, this versatile set can be used for a wide range of culinary treats from chocolate chip cookies to crispy french fries. The trays conveniently stack into each other when not in use, making them simple to store even in smaller kitchens.
Not only are these baking trays great value, they’re also guaranteed for a year, bringing you plenty of baking for your bucks. Keep an eye on the temperature, however, as some reviewers found they warped slightly when they got too hot. Whilst they’re labelled as dishwasher safe, we would also err on the side of caution and hand wash where possible to prolong the life of the non-stick coating.
Related: The best knife sharpener, as tried and tested by Mumsnet users
3. Best heavy-duty baking tray: Le Creuset Rectangular Baking Sheet
Price on writing: £30 | Buy now from Amazon
Key specs
Maximum temperature: Oven safe up to 240°C | Dishwasher safe: No | Material: Carbon steel | Size: 31 x 31 x 1.5 cm | Guarantee: Lifetime
What we like
Lifetime guarantee
Made from robust carbon steel
Heats evenly without warping
Rolled edge with silicone inserts for grip
Freezer safe
What we don’t like
Hand wash only
Prone to scratching easily
Costly
What Mumsnet users say
“My husband bought me two Le Creuset non-stick baking trays for Christmas and I’ve been using them non-stop the last few days. Nothing sticks to them. They’re a dream.” (Tried and tested by Mumsnet user Pugliandreamer)
“Le Creuset baking tray, the small one is £15. Nothing has stuck yet and I've had it about one year so far.” (Rated by Mumsnet user livingthegoodlife)
Our verdict
French cookware company Le Creuset is renowned for being top of the pots (their casserole dishes and cast iron skillets are particularly raved about), and their flawless design extends to baking trays and sheets, too.
Made of strong carbon steel, this heavy-duty sheet is up to every task, whatever you’re baking. Its non-stick coating ensures that food will glide off effortlessly and it can easily be hand washed after use without the need to soak or scrub.
We love the heat-resistant silicone handles, helping provide additional grip whilst safely lifting your creations from the oven to the countertop. Although it’s one of the pricier oven trays available, the lifetime warranty provides great peace of mind for your investment.
4. Best non-stick baking tray: Circulon Momentum Square Baking Tray
Price on writing: £17 | Buy now from Amazon
Key specs
Maximum temperature: Oven safe to 230°C | Dishwasher safe: Yes | Material: Steel | Size: 37 x 34 x 1.5 cm | Guarantee: Lifetime
What we like
Textured Circulon non-stick system allows simple food release
Good depth
Does not warp at high heat
What we don’t like
Need to clean off immediately after use to prevent food from getting embedded into the Circulon system
What Mumsnet users say
“I love my Circulon baking tins and trays. [The] only truly non-stick ones I’ve used.” (Tried and tested by Mumsnet user VanillaSpiceCandle)
“Circulon, the more expensive range that they do. I’ve had mine for over 10 years now and
the matching pans are nearly 20 years old.” (Recommended by Mumsnet user JaceLancs)
Our verdict
If non-stick capabilities are on your priority list, this may just be the baking tray for you. Its manufacturer is so confident of this tray’s effectiveness that it guarantees your food will not stick – as long as you care for it well.
Circular grooves on the base of this baking tray help prevent your food from clinging to the surface, making it far easier to clean and requiring less cooking oil as a result. The brand recommends you wash as soon as possible after use to protect the non-stick coating, whether that’s by hand or simply rinsing through your dishwasher.
This spacious, square baking tray is a generous 1.5cm deep, providing plenty of room to spread out your culinary creations and allow them to cook evenly across the entire tray. The best part? With a lifetime guarantee, you could easily pass it on to your grandkids when it’s their turn to cook for you.
Related: Discover the best cutlery sets, from budget-friendly to luxurious
5. Best glass baking tray: Pyrex Baking Tray
Price on writing: £11 | Buy now from Amazon
Key specs
Maximum temperature: Oven safe to 300°C | Dishwasher safe: Yes | Material: Pyrex | Size: 32 x 26 x 2 cm | Guarantee: One year
What we like
Oven safe, microwave safe and dishwasher safe
Very deep tin for roasting veg and potatoes with olive oil
Very easy to clean
What we don’t like
Heavy
Less suited to baking with kids
Takes longer to preheat that carbon/stainless steel
What Mumsnet users say
“Pyrex glass ones here! Ridiculously heavy but take anything including the dishwasher.” (Tried and tested by Mumsnet user Coffeeonadrip)
“Pyrex glass! We’ve just bought some and they’re a revelation!” (Recommended by Mumsnet user hollyivysaurus)
Our verdict
If you’re tired of attempting to restore your carbon or steel baking trays to their former glory, you may want to consider Pyrex as an alternative, with many Mumsnet users claiming they’ll never look back after having made the switch.
Whilst they’re heavier than traditional baking trays and may take a little longer to preheat, these hard-wearing Pyrex trays are suitable for both microwave and oven baking and can be used at significantly high temperatures, without the risk of shattering or warping during use. They’re also safe to pop in the freezer should you wish to do so.
Unlike some steel trays, Pyrex is straightforward to clean and can be washed by hand or simply popped in the dishwasher to have them sparkling clean and next to new in no time. The biggest shift is psychological – it may take a while to mentally adjust to using glass for your family’s Friday night fish fingers.
6. Best baking tray set: Tala High-Performance Set of 3 Baking Trays
Price on writing: £23 | Buy now from Amazon
Key specs
Maximum temperature: Oven safe up to 240°C | Dishwasher safe: Yes | Material: Carbon steel | Size: One 34.5 x 24.4 cm tray, two 25 x 18 cm trays | Guarantee: 10 years
What we like
Two different size trays in the set
Fridge, freezer and dishwasher safe
Robust heavy gauge carbon steel
Durable non-stick coating
10-year guarantee
What we don’t like
Some reviewers found that water trapped under the rim and caused the tins to rust
What Mumsnet users say
“I have a set of black Tala baking trays. Had them over 12 months now and they seem to be doing okay.” (Tried and tested by Mumsnet user OvaHere)
“Tala, about six years old, still going well. Always used with a silicone liner.” (Recommended by Mumsnet user IbizaToTheNorfolkBroads)
Our verdict
If you’re after a versatile baking tray set that is suitable for batch cooking, baking and roasting, this set of three heavyweight trays from Tala is a great place to start. At just £23 for three tins (in two different sizes), they offer great value for money, too.
With a durable non-stick coating, your food will be quick and easy to release without leaving stubborn, dried-on burnt bits that need scrubbing or soaking. Made from strong carbon steel, they’re also excellent heat conductors, ensuring consistent cooking results without warping or bending in the oven.
The brand claims the products are fridge, freezer and dishwasher safe. However, we recommend hand washing whenever possible as some reviewers found water gets trapped in the rim when cleaning in the dishwasher –something that can cause your tins to rust and deteriorate over time.
7. Most versatile baking tray: Mermaid Hard Anodised Baking Sheet
Price on writing: £30 | Buy now from Amazon
Key specs
Maximum temperature: Oven safe up to 240°C | Dishwasher safe: No | Material: Aluminium | Size: 41.6 x 30.6 x 1.8 cm | Guarantee: Lifetime
What we like
The hard anodised surface will develop a natural patina over time
Robust and long-lasting
Large size
What we don’t like
Not dishwasher safe
Some reviewers claim it marks easily
Costly
What Mumsnet users say
“Mermaid Anodised: not cheap, but not outrageously expensive either. Substantial and robust. None of my Mermaids have warped or in any way deformed in up to 20 years of constant use.” (Tried and tested by Mumsnet user Dilbertian)
“Samuel Groves Mermaid range, but VERY expensive and can't go in the dishwasher because they warp. They are not coated as such but are non-stick if treated as per instructions.” (Recommended by Mumsnet user Georgyporky)
Our verdict
Mermaid baking trays and sheets come highly recommended by Mumsnet users for their superior quality and sturdiness. A strong and solidly-made piece of bakeware, it will do its job without bending or buckling, with a natural patina that will build up over time to make it completely non-stick.
This anodised aluminium baking sheet has a multitude of uses, as well as a super-smooth surface. Being rimless, it is particularly well-suited to cooking items that need to be transferred to a cooling rack with minimal hassle, such as cookies and biscuits. The lack of raised edges also aids the sheet’s cleaning and prevents rust, making it simple to clean despite being hand wash only.
Related: The best salt and pepper grinders for stylish seasoning
8. Best enamel baking tray: ProCook Enamel Baking Tray
Price on writing: £11 | Buy now from ProCook
Key specs
Maximum temperature: Oven safe up to 260°C | Dishwasher safe: Yes | Material: Enamel and carbon steel | Size: 41cm x 32cm x 2.5cm | Guarantee: 10 years
What we like
Tough scratch-resistant enamel surface
Made from robust heavy gauge carbon steel
Low price point
Large size
Dishwasher safe
What we don’t like
Requires light oiling before use to aid food release
What Mumsnet users say
“We have a set from ProCook, which I reckon would protect me from a bullet. Two years on, don’t have a scratch on them.” (Tried and tested by Mumsnet user JustKeepLookingWithYourEyes)
Our verdict
With a substantial surface size, this heavy gauge carbon steel baking tray from Mumsnetter-trusted brand ProCook is ideal for those who want to batch cook or cater for larger families at home.
Unlike some non-stick coatings that can deteriorate over time, this tray comes with a tough enamelled coating that is both durable and scratch resistant, hence the generous ten-year guarantee.
It’ll need lightly oiling before use to aid food release, but this tray can withstand high temperatures of up to 260°C and is suitable for use on the hob. Plus, it can even be popped in the dishwasher once you’re done.
9. Most stylish baking trays: Prestige x Nadiya Non-Stick Baking Tray Set of 2
Price on writing: £23 | Buy now from Amazon
Key specs
Maximum temperature: Oven safe to 180°C | Dishwasher safe: Yes | Material: Heavy gauge steel | Size: 33 x 23cm; 39 x 25cm | Guarantee: 10 years
What we like
Durable steel
Freezer and dishwasher safe
Stylish design
What we don’t like
Low maximum temperature
What Mumsnet users say
“Prestige heavy gauge ones have been great. We used to be forever replacing baking trays.” (Recommended by Mumsnet user BobbinAround)
Our verdict
Nadiya Hussain first rose to fame on Great British Bake Off, so when it comes to preventing soggy bottoms, she certainly knows a thing or two.
In her recent collaboration with kitchenware brand Prestige, Nadiya has released her own range of non-stick bakeware, including cake tins and baking trays ideal for cooking fresh biscuits, macaroons or cupcakes to perfection.
The blue and black design with textured pattern to the base isn’t just a pretty face, the stylish textured design is raised to assist air flow and food release, allowing excellent heat distribution for a crisp and even bake.
With a heavy gauge makeup and a ten-year guarantee, the only downside is the maximum temperature, which is quite low for bakeware – recommended to be used at no higher than 180 degrees.
10. Best dishwasher-safe baking tray: Lakeland Multi-Purpose Oven Tray
Price on writing: £13 | Buy now from Lakeland
Key specs
Maximum temperature: Oven safe up to 240°C | Dishwasher safe: Yes | Material: Carbon steel | Size: 42 x 27 x 2.5cm (including handles) | Guarantee: Three years
What we like
Handles with sure-grip silicone inserts
Two layers of Quantum 2 professional non-stick
Stylish design
Dishwasher safe
No rolled edges
What we don’t like
Some reviewers found it buckles and warps easily at a high temp
What Mumsnet users say
“Lakeland plastics heavy duty ones – not forever, but [I've] had for a good six years plus (and I do shove them in the dishwasher).” (Brand tried and tested by Mumsnet user Cantchooseaname)
“Another vote for Lakeland.” (Recommended by Mumsnet user Johnnysgirl)
Our verdict
A robust multi-purpose option, this high-quality Lakeland baking tray can be used for a variety of cooking requirements - whether that's roasting vegetables for your Sunday lunch or tasty home baking with the kids.
With a stylish design made from sturdy carbon steel, it has a double layer Quantum 2 professional non-stick coating for simple food release whilst still being completely dishwasher safe. Thanks to the lack of rolled edges, there’s nowhere for water to get trapped, reducing the risk of the tray rusting prematurely. Some reviewers did notice some warping at high temperatures however.
We love the large carry handles with silicone inserts for grip, ensuring a safe journey from oven to countertop even when wearing oven gloves.
Related: Enhance weekend brunch with the best egg poachers
11. Best supermarket baking tray: Sainsbury's Home Oven Tray Black Large
Price on writing: £10 | Buy now from Sainsbury’s
Key specs
Maximum temperature: Not specified | Dishwasher safe: Yes | Material: Carbon steel | Size: 41 x 28.5cm | Guarantee: Not specified
What we like
Large and extra-large sizes available in the Sainsbury's range
Sturdy carbon steel
What we don’t like
Not very deep for roasting with olive oil
What Mumsnet users say
”The Sainsbury’s ones - heavyweight, very dark grey with the dark purple label. I buy on offer unless I really want an item straight away.” (Brand recommended by Mumsnet user 70isaLimitNotaTarget)
Our verdict
You may question whether supermarket options are as effective as baking trays from cookware brands, but Mumsnet users were really impressed with the premium Sainsbury’s Collection oven trays, thanks to their heavyweight carbon steel construction and effective non-stick coating.
Stackable with other items from the range and with a variety of sizes available, they can even be cleaned in the dishwasher to reduce the time spent washing up.
What is the best material for a baking tray?
There are a variety of different materials used for baking trays and which choice is best for you will depend upon your needs:
Metal
Metal bakeware such as stainless steel and carbon steel warm up quickly and can withstand high temperatures. A popular choice with many bakers, they will brown your food better than a tray made from other materials.
Glass
While glass trays are slower to heat, they can stay hotter for longer. Sweeter foods may therefore bake quicker than expected and will burn more easily, so reduce the temperature or save these trays for savoury bakes. You should also bear in mind that glass trays are heavier than other kinds.
Silicone
Silicone is the ultimate non-stick material and baking mats made from it are well worth a look, as are liners that replace foil, oil and parchment, with no greasing required.
How to choose the best baking tray
Who’d have thought there were so many factors to take into account when you’re in the market for a baking tray? In addition to the baking tray’s material, here are some things to consider when making your choice.
How robust is it?: The stronger the material, the less likely it is to warp in the oven at high temperatures. For the highest quality baking trays, you should look for thick, sturdy construction made from materials such as heavy gauge carbon steel, anodised steel or enamel – the latter of which tends to be the most scratch resistant.
Non-stick coating: The most prevalent baking trays are those that have a non-stick coating. While these have an obvious advantage, many need to be hand washed and can be damaged by metal utensils like spatulas. Non-coated trays, however, have the drawback that food is more likely to stick and more scrubbing may be required as a result.
Size and shape: In terms of shape, certain trays and sheets lend themselves better to particular bakes. Those with rimmed sides prevent your precious creations from slipping off, while at the same time catching oil, juices and other liquids. They make for slower baking than sheets without edges, however, which cook quicker by allowing better air circulation in the oven and are convenient when making goodies such as pizzas and cookies.
Ease of carrying: Some thin and shallow baking trays can be tricky to grip through your oven gloves, so those with carry handles and silicone grips can prevent the risk of spilling your creations.
Ease of cleaning: Is your baking tray dishwasher safe? Some baking trays need to be washed by hand, whilst others are safe to be popped in the dishwasher for a quick refresh after use. It’s worth noting that trays with rolled edges risk trapped water, so we would always opt to hand wash where possible in order to prolong their life.
Where can I use it?: Check the maximum temperature for your baking trays, as well as whether they can be used in the freezer.
Price: Last but not least, how much are you willing to spend? Whilst some trays may seem expensive, it’s often a case of you get what you pay for, with more expensive trays tending to offer a more heavy-duty construction and a longer guarantee. That said, you can still pick up some high-quality trays at a low price point, or opt for tray sets which can offer excellent value for money.
How long do baking trays last?
If you choose wisely, baking trays can last for years or even decades – ideally at least five years. Look out for manufacturers’ guarantees, some of which cover the product for life.
What is the best baking tray?
The best baking tray is the Scoville Neverstick Baking Tray which came well rated by Mumsnet users and reviewers alike. Despite its shallow nature, this generously sized baking tray is made from robust aluminium and can be used to cook a wide range of food from treats to full meals.
With excellent heat distribution, a strong non-stick coating and a lifetime guarantee, it’s designed to be practical, look smart and last for decades.
The best way to clean baking trays
Clean your baking tray immediately if possible – it will be harder to remove dirt the longer you leave it.
First, use kitchen roll to remove the worst of the grease and grime from the baking tray. Many trays can then just be wiped clean or put through the dishwasher.
Those that aren't dishwasher safe should be cleaned with washing-up liquid and a cloth or sponge if they’re non-stick – no wire wool pads or scourers should be used as they will scratch the coating and cause it to deteriorate. Non-stick trays can also be soaked for at least an hour in warm, soapy water before being cleaned and dried thoroughly.
Baking trays and sheets that don’t have a non-stick coating can be scrubbed with metal scourers, ideally in water that is hot enough to shift all grease. Many Mumsnetters use biological washing powder to clean theirs, which is said to work wonders. Others recommend using dishwasher tablets.
However you choose to clean your bakeware, be sure to follow the manufacturer’s instructions.
How we chose our recommendations
We first headed to the Mumsnet forums to find out which baking trays and sheets discerning Mumsnetters recommended and had bought themselves, noting their feedback about these brands. We then drew up a shortlist of those that were repeatedly mentioned.
From there, we did some research across the wider web, consulting independent review sites and taking into account what customer reviews said about the products featured. Having collated all that information, we picked the baking trays we thought were worthy of taking the titles in an array of interest categories.
About the author
Lucy Cotterill is a Content Writer at Mumsnet, specialising in baby/child and lifestyle product reviews and roundups. Having written product reviews on her own blog Real Mum Reviews since 2012, Lucy loves to research and explore the pros and cons of products, scrutinising reviews and exploring consumer feedback to help parents make confident purchases that benefit their families.
Lucy loves to bake with her kids, as well as opting for quick and easy oven dinners during the week for her children. As a result, she’s tried and tested a fair share of oven trays in her time, including some bad, some good and some downright ugly options, so she knows the power of finding the perfect tray for your kitchen.
Why you should trust us
We work hard to provide unbiased, independent advice you can trust. We do sometimes earn revenue through affiliate (click-to-buy) links in our articles. This helps us fund more helpful articles like this one.