OK, the general consensus seems to be for the IO dress and that the Toast dress is a no-go. (I still love the print on it)

I think the IO dress would be more flattering and good for my shape...
So I'm thinking sheer tights and black patent (chunky-ish/ platformy?) heels would go best (with either red or black dress).

But where do I find them? And have I missed the boat ito patent?

Can't remember the last time I bought substantial heels.

The IO dress is gorgeous - you HAVE to go for that one

The toast dress is terrible. It doesn't look flattering on the model so that would rule out any dress. The green hem looks rumpled. No.

The IO dress looks fab. Very flattering.

WC - hard to tell because the model is sitting down innit. May well be a bit dull.

Okay - keeping in mind that I hate both shoes and Next, there seem to be quite few pairs on the Next site:
here but I don't like them

Monsoon but I don't like these either

bit mad but I quite like them

lol at being a careful eater

I think with your colouring you could easily wear the red & look great, but if you're unsure maybe stick with black - you have to feel at ease with what you're wearing.

I was trying to find pewter shoes last month to wear to a wedding, trust me its not easy! Gave up in the end and wore some old silver ones I already had...so I cant be any help either!

bless, janeite, thanks anyway

I like the toast one.

Sorry - I know nothing about shoes as I detest shoes: I just thought it sounded good! I bet there are shoe-people out there who could find some though.

Have just seen the Toast dress and don't like it, sorry.

oooh, mixed opinions...

Sponge- I'm pale olive with mid brown hair and dark eyes (pasty, shorter version of the gorgeous model). I think I'm tall enough for dress 2 and I'm a careful eater

Geordieminx- I do so love the red but I want to wear the dress rather than the dress wear me. I think I'm not dark enough for that bright a red? <safe emoticon>

Janeite- I live the idea of pewter w dress 3. Accessories can make all the difference- but where does one find pewter shoes? <flat shoe/ toddler chaser emoticon!>

Any votes for the Toast dress?- typical me to get the wrong link up.

The red looks far too long. I think unless you're tall, it's going to be mid shin.

Which is not good.

the toast dress is expensive and shapeless. And looks like a day dress, not for a formal dinner.

The WC dress is ok but safe. At least you could dress it up a bit.