Am I too fat for this Oasis winter rose dress? Be honest.

(123 Posts)
Butteredsidedown Sat 19-Oct-13 18:20:31

Photos in profile

I have fat arms, this doesn't do good things to them as the pudgy above elbow bit is showing.

Also wearing spanx here but the split means the thunder thigh holding in bits might be seen, so the dress is spanx prohibitive. Other pant options would be needed.

Should I send it back and just accept I need a nice mumsy wrap dress that covers all the fat bits?

AndTwoBits Thu 24-Oct-13 20:29:44

Agree with others, keep the teal and the black, they are both fabulous on you, teal for the wedding, black for dh! The other dress isn't working. I love your hair colour and red lipstick. I have the same hair colour and am wearing red lips out on sat night! Delighted you found two great dresses.

OneMoreThenNoMore Thu 24-Oct-13 20:26:26

Yes- stick with the teal for the wedding, but keep the black one anyway! grin

And the red lips suit you, go for it.

Pinupgirl Thu 24-Oct-13 19:55:50

If you are looking for any other Collectif dresses I can recommend the Regina style-not as much room in the boobs though so I take a 16 in this-the Violet dress but again size up.

If you are looking for any xmas party dresses then I think the Delilah dress would be stunning on your figure<I must not buy any more collectif dresses!>

Pinupgirl Thu 24-Oct-13 19:52:42

Yes the teal for the wedding but I would keep the black Dolores too-you always need a little black dress and this one looks amazing on you!

You MUST wear the hat,red lippy and seamed stockings!<stern glare>

Butteredsidedown Thu 24-Oct-13 17:36:32

DH says he agrees wholeheartedly!

Ok I'll do it. Thanks for all your advice, it's greatly appreciated.

goodasitgets Thu 24-Oct-13 17:29:46

Teal for wedding
Black for DH wink
I agree about the other, I don't like it as much
Hair looks fab! And wear the bloody red lipstick grin

Butteredsidedown Thu 24-Oct-13 17:25:28

Ok last one I promise, I'm sure you are way too bored of me in these dresses.

Dilemma, the dresses I ordered came today. DH is beside himself over the black Delores, it's very tight! I think I'm going to keep it anyway, making my collectif dress total stand at 4!

I should stick with the teal yes? Not sure about black for a wedding.

The second one is the Simone dress but I think it makes my arms look like a wrestler's. Think I'm sending that back.

Plus I'm also not sure about the red lipstick now. Am I just chickening out?

Hair is, um very orange!

Pinupgirl Thu 24-Oct-13 16:22:18

I posted about those Clarks shoes before too! They are gorgeous but I am waiting until they go into the sale as I have waaaaaayy over spent lately!

Hope you have a wonderful time at the wedding!

OneMoreThenNoMore Wed 23-Oct-13 21:08:41

Oooh I like those shoes too! You must do another update with your full outfit and hairdo when you've got it all sorted. smile

DownstairsMixUp Wed 23-Oct-13 17:42:53

Agree, second dress is way better, you look fab!

goodasitgets Wed 23-Oct-13 17:35:50

Oh those shoes are beautiful! [lusts]

Butteredsidedown Wed 23-Oct-13 17:23:10

I had to just do an update.

I bought the clarks opera ticket suede shoes in black. I wasn't planning on buying these but they look so fifties pin up and are way nicer on than I expected. Oh and like walking on air.

Doing hair tonight.

Onemorethennomore - clearly you are a woman of immaculate taste!
Goodasitgets - I don't know if they are limited collection but I have two pairs of mid stilettos from m&s that I think only cost £15. I love them but in the end the lure of new shoes won!

OneMoreThenNoMore Wed 23-Oct-13 09:06:58

Wow, they both look great! Really flattering and great with your hair colour etc. I want those dresses!

Clearly we have similar tastes- you have the same fireplace as me grin

AuntyEntropy Tue 22-Oct-13 23:39:56

Oh I love a happy ending. I was scrolling down to say "you are not too fat but the dress is too frumpy", and I see that you have been found a frump-free dress already, by the S&B Posse. Looks lovely.

trixymalixy Tue 22-Oct-13 23:27:25

The teal dress is much better, really suits you. Yy to redder hair too.

soimpressed Tue 22-Oct-13 23:19:21

You look amazing in the second dress!

goodasitgets Tue 22-Oct-13 23:17:49

What shoes are you after? I have a soft spot for m&s limited collection stilettos. Not high, comfy and range of colours. Oh and £19 wink

justasecond Tue 22-Oct-13 23:07:36

I think the second outfit looks stunning on you really suits your shape and the hat goes really well.

plasticbanana Tue 22-Oct-13 23:04:01

Uh oh. Me too. Sorry. Just checked the last pics. My post was in response to your first picture. Sorry I didn't read the whole thread. Yup you look amazing!!! Well done! :-)

MillyRules Tue 22-Oct-13 22:59:02

Oooops....sorry....I was responding to the original picture but hey....I was right anyway. Tight dress and one colour. You look beautiful and sexy and great. Well done !

MillyRules Tue 22-Oct-13 22:54:51

Late to this....sorry but you are not fat but the dress does not do anything for you. It is very mumsy and curtain. You would look great in a one colour dress in a shade that suits you and a better fit to show off your great amazing shape.

plasticbanana Tue 22-Oct-13 22:54:46

Honestly? I think you're very beautiful woman. But the dress and shoes are not doing you any favours. I think it's the pattern and colour of the dress that are not working for you, and the colour and height of the shoes. Sorry, I know that sounds very negative but I think you should be aiming for a different look altogether. What is the occasion? Maybe our more stylish S&B people can find a better outfit for you.

Butteredsidedown Tue 22-Oct-13 21:43:45

Ok, just got to find seamed stockings, a burgundy clutch, and buy some more shoes. Jesus wept, weddings are pricey.

Though the dress itself was reduced to £25...

Should have got Dh to buy seamed stockings in the store, but obvs men don't do that kinda thing.

I now have a spare Delores in plain royal (like dark royal blue/purple) size 14 if anyone wants it. It was in the sale for £15. I'd say its a fairly generous 14.

Pinupgirl Tue 22-Oct-13 21:26:39

Yay!! Am so happy it fits.You look stunning.You were hiding a great figure under that horrible baggy dress.Def yes to the hat,red lippy and seamed stockings. I should get bloody commision from Collectif for the amount of times I recommend them!

Yes I prefer the collectif ones. And agree you look happier in them than the oasis one.

And your living room is also very tidy. I see a theme..

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now