My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

Connect with other parents whose children are starting secondary school on this forum.

Secondary education

Btec science - URGENT HELP PLEASE!!

59 replies

verybored · 06/01/2011 18:31

DS 1 is in year 9. Loves his science and has always hoped to do it at A level and then something science related at uni. He has come home from school today saying that he has been told they are only doind BTEC science and not GCSE.

The way his school work is they are banded into three bands and you are in this band for every subject, so you cannot be in top for English and middle for maths if that makes sense.

DS1 is in middle band and I have always been told he is at the top of that band and is only not in top band due to his attitude - which has improved massively since the beginning of year 9.

So today he has come home and told me that his band is only doing BTEC in Science. Now am I right in thinking this is not a good thing for him. I will be ringing his head of year first thing tomorrow and firstly checking the facts, then secondly asking for him to be moved up to top band, where they are apparently doing GCSE. But I'm pretty sure I will be fed the' they are GCSE equivalnets and just as good etc etc' line

If they refuse, can I do anything? I am absolutely fuming! This is his best subject, he's bloddy good at it and he's going to be lumbered with a BTEC Sad

OP posts:
Report
verybored · 06/01/2011 18:32

Apologies for crappy spelling. And so fed up with schools, it's one thing after another Sad

OP posts:
Report
floweringrose · 06/01/2011 18:52

It's absurd to put pupils in the same band for each subject - their strengths will vary across the different subjects.

Personally I'd be pushing for him to be moved up. If they refuse, I'd consider looking at the possibility of doing science GCSEs elsewhere, e.g as an external candidate/evening class/distance learning.

I did a science subject at university and it's absolutely essential to do science GCSEs in order to do A levels (preferably the single sciences, but at the very least double GCSE). Even then, GCSE to A level is a big jump so it would be even more of a struggle with a BTEC (if he could even find anywhere which would accept him).

Report
GiddyPickle · 06/01/2011 18:58

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

GiddyPickle · 06/01/2011 18:58

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

verybored · 06/01/2011 19:48

Thank you. I am bloody fuming TBH. He has worked so hard lately and only this morning showed me the results of his science test in which he got 82% with no revision and no warning of test and was by far the highest in his class.

If they won't moved him, we'll have to move schools Sad

OP posts:
Report
roisin · 06/01/2011 20:10

Yes, it is important.
BTEC is a very different course to GCSE Science.

It is an appropriate course for some students, but certainly not the majority. (But currently can result in higher results for the school... Hmm)

Can you at least warn the school that you are considering moving him, as this is important to him.

Tbh I think the banding across subjects (ie streaming) sounds pretty grim as well and inappropriate.

Report
verybored · 06/01/2011 20:16

Yes, I will give them the chance to sort it as he does not want to move, as you can imagine. I am just shocked they are doing this for a lot of very bright students - the top band is the smallest band, the middle band has the largest number of children in.

DS actually had almost an argument with the teacher about it today when she told them, as did his friend. It stinks of getting their numbers up for league tables, just as them doing 2 and a half GCSE's this year, without telling parents, in crappy little subjects, just to increase their pass rate.

OP posts:
Report
coastgirl · 06/01/2011 20:20

Yes, kick up a stink if he wants to do A level sciences. But there is no point his arguing with his teacher (I know you said "almost"!) because it is almost certainly not her decision and if she is anything like my DH, who is a science teacher, she will be against the idea of GCSE-capable students doing BTEC.

Report
TheFallenMadonna · 06/01/2011 20:22

BTEC won't count in the new style league tables, so that is unlikely to be the reason for him doing BTEC I would have thought.

I suspect it's the English baccalaureate thing (which is going to be the new measure by which schools are judged). So the top band will have a restricted choice of options (to include all the relevant subjects).

We are doing something similar, but we have 5 bands, so there is room for anyone we think could get a C at GCSE to do GCSE.

You need to ask what his target grade is for Science. If it is a C (and IME FFT targets are generally generous!), then you should be pushing for GCSE.

Report
PatTheHammer · 06/01/2011 20:24

You can also mention that BTEC Science is not allowed to be included in the new 'English bacculareate' that the government are rolling out. A reason our school is not even bothering to start the BTEC course as they are definitely now NOT equivalent as they don't count in this whereas GCSE Sciences (excpet Applied Science) do.

Report
PatTheHammer · 06/01/2011 20:26

Ex-posts Fallen Madonna!

Report
verybored · 06/01/2011 20:31

From the way DS told it, I have the impressio that the teacher doesn't like it and was actually telling the students so they would tell their parents before the options meeting we have in 2 weeks, where apparently it will all be announced. DS and his friends didn't realise this at the time but i'm pretty sure the teacher is not happy.

We were told last year that if he did no work, he would scrape C's - he's a lazy sod and last year was coasting majorly. This year he's puleed his socks up so I'm not sure what his predicted grade would be.

I didn't realie it wouldn't count towards league tables - I am even more baffled as to why they are making the mojority of the year take BTEC. It vertainly wasn't like this last year as I looked at the options book on line and all apart from a few in the bottom band took GCSE.

I feel sick about it TBH. It seems to be one problem after another with schools, and these are meant to be fairly good schools.

OP posts:
Report
TheFallenMadonna · 06/01/2011 20:47

We are still going to do BTEC with some of our students, because we think it is a better course for them. But not with any student who could get a C or higher at GCSE. You do need to ask about target grades - and I mean specific target grades. Ask them about FFT targets!

There is always the problem that we have to group students into classes, so we couldn't for example have 40 students doing GCSE and 15 doing BTEC, because we would only be able to have two classes on those numbers. It's a bit awkward when you are running completely different courses in the same subject.

Report
TheFallenMadonna · 06/01/2011 20:49

His target grade won't be his predicted grade - they are different things. Target grades are calculated on a number of things, none of which are motivation or recent work rate.

Report
verybored · 06/01/2011 20:53

They weren't official targets, they were just comments to do with the fact that he's bright but lazy. Is it a GCSE target i'm asking for, and if it's C or higher he should be doing GCSE, is that right?

OP posts:
Report
TheFallenMadonna · 06/01/2011 22:22

Probably - it would be our default choice IYSWIM.

But then, we do have to take into account everything we know about the student, and we do have to take into account class sizes too. Sadly, that is going to be a factor. It can't not be.

Report
verybored · 06/01/2011 22:33

It's a pretty big school, almost 300 in the year group so I can't imagine it's a problem as there must ne lots at the same level. Will have to see what the school say in the morning. Thanks for your help.

OP posts:
Report
TheFallenMadonna · 06/01/2011 22:39

What level is he working at?

Report
verybored · 06/01/2011 22:44

Just got a level 6 in a sats paper but that was the highest level you can get on that paper. He was predicted level 6 for end of year 9 but was achieving it by the end of year 8. I don't know if thats his prediction, or what he should be ale to get.

OP posts:
Report
verybored · 06/01/2011 22:45

able

OP posts:
Report
TheFallenMadonna · 06/01/2011 22:48

Hmm. You need to speak to the teacher in the first instance I think, and see if she said that he was definitely doing BTEC. And then if so, speak to the Head of Science. I am sorting out next year's groups now, and I have no-one getting a level 6 now in a BTEC group. I know other school do things differently, and I know that some schools in fact ONLY do BTEC and push their better students to get distinctions. BUT until the Wolf report comes out, BTEC is in a bit of a limbo, and I would (and am) going with GCSE for those who could do OK in that.

Report
verybored · 06/01/2011 22:52

He is definite the teacher said they are doing BTEC but some of the top band are doing GCSE, but not all the top band.

Can I ask is level 6 ok for this point in year 9? He got 82% of the test right, no revision and he did say they hadn't covered all the subjects in the paper (but I take this with a pinch of salt!) Levels mean nothing to me at all. the precentage sounds good, but not if it's a really easy test!

OP posts:
Report

Don’t want to miss threads like this?

Weekly

Sign up to our weekly round up and get all the best threads sent straight to your inbox!

Log in to update your newsletter preferences.

You've subscribed!

TheFarSide · 06/01/2011 22:57

I've come across this problem in local secondary schools in East London - able year 9 kids who are considering careers where GCSE science is crucial somehow ending up on BTEC courses.

We've had a couple of dramas where kids have not been allowed to do A level science subjects with a BTEC science at GCSE level.

It's totally outrageous and in my experience is absolutely to do with clocking up extra passes to improve league table rankings.

Schools must NOT be allowed to f**k with students' futures to suit their own needs.

Make an ENORMOUS fuss! If possible/appropriate, enlist the help of the local careers/connexions service or the local education authority.

Report
TheFallenMadonna · 06/01/2011 23:25

It's a level where I would put the student in for GCSE. It's hard to say whether it is good for your DS because I don't know what he should be getting. Ignore percentages - they depend entirely on the test. Always look at the level.

I'll repeat for TheFarSide that for this year group, BTEC will absolutely NOT improve the school's position in the league tables. In fact, that's what surprises me about this. It is the English Bacc on which schools will be judged now, and that means GCSE in Science.

Report
TheFarSide · 06/01/2011 23:53

FallenMadonna, I thought the EBacc was just an additional measure and other measures of performance will still stand for the time being, especially as this is a very new development and state schools are up in arms about what is and isn't included in the EBac.

To date, though, is it not generally accepted that schools have used vocational subjects like the old GNVQ (and BTECs) to boost their position in the league tables?

Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.