I promised to come back on here and give an update on how my appeal went. I asked for the original thread to be removed as it outed my DC somewhat.
Well, we were successful in what was an ICS appeal. The Panel ruled in our favour as we fulfilled the admissions criteria for church criteria. two children won their appeal so the class will be 32. Sadly for them many more, double figures, went to appeal and lost.
The panel and clerk did everything to make the hearing easy. I wasn't impressed by the school, their case wasn't strong so they relied on character assassination, that hurt, a lot. I could have done without having my parenting skills called into question.
So, what did we do? Well we accepted the school we were given and went on the waiting list for every other school in our and our neighbouring borough. So by the time the appeal came up we had a place at a school we were very happy with, all be it was a distance from us. We only got into this school because it ran a bulge class this year, it would not have been an option before.
I spent many sleepless nights getting information together, I went through the Admissis Code, I wrote down important conversations I remembered, I got witness statements, I wrote a chronology of events.
What didn't win people appeals was; that they have siblings at the school as it wasn't the highest criteria; difficulty of getting two children to two different schools; having the uniform; the appealed for school having a better Ofsted than the one they were given; that it wasn't fair; no one had told the parents the admission criteria. I am sure the Panel were sympathetic, but there wasn't anything they could do.
Interestingly the appeal panel said that only information given at the time of application may be used in deciding a school place. You can't carry on going to church from January and put in a new supplementary form in May and move up the waiting list. Also if you have already applied, and then move house nearer the school, this can't be taken into consideration until the 1st September. Now I know some schools I the area haven't been. Following this rule and I don't know where it comes from, but it's what my Borough uses.
Many, many thanks to everyone that helped my, and special thanks to Prh47bridge who went above and beyond. As someone on here said " listen to him"! Thanks to Tiggy and admissions and Bella who went though it with me.
So that's it really. Is there anything else useful I could add that would help people going through appeals?
Please or to access all these features
Please
or
to access all these features
Join our Primary Education forum to discuss starting school and helping your child get the most out of it.
Primary education
Remember Greeneggs and " did the Church/school make a mistake".
21 replies
GreenEggsAndNaiceHam · 05/07/2013 12:30
OP posts:
tiggytape ·
07/07/2013 20:12
This reply has been deleted
Message withdrawn at poster's request.
tiggytape ·
07/07/2013 21:52
This reply has been deleted
Message withdrawn at poster's request.
tiggytape ·
07/07/2013 22:15
This reply has been deleted
Message withdrawn at poster's request.
Please create an account
To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.