My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

Is your child ready for potty training at nursery? Here's the place for all your toilet training questions.

Potty training

17 MO pooing in potty - I don't think he's ready.

10 replies

LetThereBeCupcakes · 26/06/2014 19:19

OK, bit of backstory. My mum bought DS a potty a few weeks back. I thought she was mad, but she said it was a good idea to just leave it in the house for him to play with / get used to etc. Made sense, so we did. It's in the bathroom.

2 days ago, DS was in the bath and started to make his "poo face", so I hoiked him out and sat him on the potty, where he had a poo. He was rather impressed and tried to eat it, as it meant he could then get back in the bath, whereas previously pooing at bath time has had to mean the end of the bath for obvious reasons.

I didn't think much of it really, but tonight he was sitting in the bath, then suddenly stood up and pointed to his potty, so I got him out of the bath. He sat down and had a poo. He then got up, but changed his mind and sat back down again and pooed a bit more. He seemed very aware that he wanted to poo in the potty. He then got up and motioned to get back in the bath.

So, I'm probably sounding a bit bonkers and you're wondering why I'm posting. My concern is that I don't think he's ready to potty train. His speech isn't overly developed yet so beyond pointing at the potty he won't be able to tell me that he needs it. He does occasionally pull at his nappy when he's weeing, and if his nappy is wet and he needs a poo he will ask to be changed. But if I tried full-on potty training, I'm pretty sure he'd have no idea what I'm going on about.

In addition, we have family who live 4 hours away so often go on long car journeys. I'm thinking DS is far too young to be able to hold on so surely potty training early would be a total disaster in this respect.

What's the best thing for me to do? I don't want to discourage his interest but at the same time I don't want to confuse him! FWIW I have PND and get a bit anxious about doing things "right" for DS so please excuse me if I'm coming across as a bit neurotic!

OP posts:
Report
Georgethesecond · 26/06/2014 19:25

Don't worry OP, these are good signs and you can't "miss the boat". Let him go on it if he asks, sit him on it regularly to see what happens, esp at bath time, but keep him in nappies otherwise.

Report
TeWiSavesTheDay · 26/06/2014 19:26

A couple of months ago my DS (now 2.5) started doing this kind of thing. It wasn't at all convenient and he has some speech/understanding issues so I just ignored it! But we did start offering him the potty, and getting it for him if he wanted to use it.

However we've just started pt and it's going fine, so I don't think it's caused any trouble to keep him in nappies until we were more sure he was ready - there is still a jump from using the potty when child happens to want to and using it all day when they are busy playing etc.

Report
Dontstepinthecowpat · 26/06/2014 19:27

I would let him to continue to use the potty but wear nappies IYSWIM. I don't think he would have bladder/bowel control at that age to be properly trained.

I'm sure there will be someone my MIL along in a min to say that their DC was potty trained at nine months, but I'm only going on my experience Grin

DD is two and no where ready but she has developmental delays, her brothers were out of nappies around 2.5

Report
Trillions · 26/06/2014 19:50

He doesn't need to be able to speak. Isn't it true that most children in the developing world are trained long before they start talking? He is communicating with you by making his poo face! I certainly wouldn't be discouraging anything that reduces the amount of poo you need to deal with ??

Report
kaffkooks · 28/06/2014 16:51

I'm in a similar situation with my 18 month old. His childminder's son is a year older and using the potty so ds has decided he wants to use it too. I have kept him in nappies but both me and CM let him sit on the potty when he wants to, which is usually when someone else is on the toilet. Problem I have now is that he is getting distressed when he pees in his nappy as he can feel it as he's in reusables. I'm giving him lots of nappy off time and considering reusable pull ups which are quicker to take off.

Report
ItsAllGoingToBeFine · 28/06/2014 16:55

Wear nappies but take him to toilet regularly. DD only ever pooed in toilet at about this age, and leas shitty nappies is never a bad thing!

Of course he can't be toilet trained, as he cannot independently toilet but he can signal to you that he needs to go, and you can respond to this.

Report
Trillions · 28/06/2014 18:07

OP, you might find this interesting: www.webmd.com/parenting/features/bye-bye-diapers

or google "baby led potty training" :)

Report
amothersplaceisinthewrong · 28/06/2014 18:09

My daughter was clean and dry at 18 months....her choosing, she just said no nappy one day and that was it.

Is that being "baby led" (no such phrase existed back in the day, and being an old person, I don't subscribe to anything baby or child led)

Report
catkind · 28/06/2014 19:04

lol amother - think it's fair to say that if you let her choose she was kind of leading no? Wink

We had a little go at potty training with DD at 17 months as she was doing all her poos and most pees in the toilet, dry at night etc. Gave it a couple of weeks and she didn't seem to be quite getting it so we put her back in nappies. Perhaps we should have carried on, she was only having 1 accident a day or so, I'd have killed for that success rate with DS at 3!
But we figured she was very little and there was no hurry. Carried on using the toilet whenever she wanted, before going out etc - she'd often be in the same dry nappy all day and night.

We had another go at 2.2 and she got it straight away, so I don't think all that practice was going to waste. I didn't think it'd make much difference but actually it's lovely not to have to faff around with nappies, even dry ones.

Report
LetThereBeCupcakes · 30/06/2014 13:50

Sorry for going quiet - we were camping for the weekend and no internet access.

Thanks for all the messages! We did baby led weaning so I guess baby led potty training is a natural follow on! Trillions yes you are right - he is communicating. I was trying to say in a clumsy way that as his only method at the moment is to point to his potty, he wouldn't be able to tell me he needed a poo if no potty was nearby and I didn't know if he would get confused / upset by that. Maybe I should just buy more potties!

OP posts:
Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.