My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

Pedants' corner

Didn't want fed

14 replies

belindarose · 15/01/2013 20:48

or 'didn't need fed'.

I keep seeing this horrid turn of phrase all over mumsnet. What happened to 'to be'? Do people speak like this now? (I wouldn't know -I'm a hermit).

OP posts:
Report
Porkster · 15/01/2013 20:49

Ghastly.

Report
AMumInScotland · 15/01/2013 20:49

They're probably Scottish! It's perfectly normal grammar up here Grin

Report
belindarose · 15/01/2013 20:50

Is it really? Maybe they are all Scottish then...?

OP posts:
Report
BooBooChicken · 15/01/2013 20:54

Agree, it is a scottish turn of phrase Grin

Report
AMumInScotland · 15/01/2013 20:55

Yes, it's quite the usual way of putting things - "This shirt needs ironed" , "The floor needs swept" etc. My BIL (SE England) gets quite ratty about how we're saying things "wrong", but I ask who gave his area the right to decide the only "correct" way of saying things Grin

Report
belindarose · 15/01/2013 20:56

Well, you live and learn. I'll assume the perpetrators are Scottish and stop being annoyed then! Thanks.

OP posts:
Report
Trills · 15/01/2013 20:58

What a lovely response :)

I haven't actually seen this.

Report
belindarose · 15/01/2013 21:01

Well, I do hang around on baby sleep threads where much discussion of whether they do or do not need feeding goes on!

OP posts:
Report
AgentProvocateur · 15/01/2013 21:02

What would you say? Didn't want to be fed? That sounds so odd to my Scottish ears. I love language idiosyncrasies.

Report
DSM · 15/01/2013 21:04

I hate the term 'need feeding'.

The bucket needs filling. No, it needs to be filled.
Your hair needs cutting. No, it needs cut.
The baby needs feeding. No, it needs fed.

Annoys me.

Report
belindarose · 15/01/2013 21:05

Yes, would definitely use 'to be' in there. Sounds so odd otherwise to my English ears! But I didn't realise it was a dialect thing. Very interesting.

And Blush that I must assume all posters are English. Mental note duly made.

OP posts:
Report
AMumInScotland · 15/01/2013 21:15

I think we all start assuming our dialect/grammar are the norm, and are surprised to find it's not the case! I hadn't even realised the Scottish pattern was specifically Scottish until BIL started telling me I was "wrong"!

Report
streakybacon · 16/01/2013 07:18

Very common in the north east too. You're a freak if you get it right in these parts.

Report
JessieMcJessie · 22/01/2013 17:11

Streaky, the construction IS right, it is an acceptable dialect variation. I had been living in England for at least 6 years before a close friend pointed out that my "the shirt needs ironed" sounded wrong to his ears. If we are going to split hairs, the absolutely correct grammar is "the shirt needs to be ironed". So the Scottish phrasing is a lot closer to the correct grammar than the English "the shirt needs ironing", with its rogue present participle.

Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.