My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

For free parenting resources please check out the Early Years Alliance's Family Corner.

Parenting

According to Steve Biddulph, if you are honest with your kids and don't do them down they will be happy...

29 replies

fillyjonk · 29/06/2007 18:26

have I got it right?

oh yes and you need to put a positive spin on things.

but anger is ok.

if you do all this then they will share and express their emotions perfectly and know their colours at an early age?

Is this correct?

OP posts:
Report
WendyWeber · 29/06/2007 18:31

Pass

Report
NoodleStroodle · 29/06/2007 18:32

It sounds impossible

Report
Greensleeves · 29/06/2007 18:32

I bloody hope so

Report
fillyjonk · 29/06/2007 18:34

oh crap

ds doesn't know his colours and he is SHY which is cardinal sin # 12 with biddulph

am regretting buying the sodding book now

OP posts:
Report
Greensleeves · 29/06/2007 18:36

how old is he?

colours schmolours, woman, he'll learn them when he wants to

and for "shy" read "interesting thoughtful child whose Mind Is On Higher Things"

Report
NotQuiteCockney · 29/06/2007 18:37

I'm doing talk/listen/listen/talk. I can't be having this 'boys are like this' malarkey, tbh.

Report
NoodleStroodle · 29/06/2007 18:38

I do shout, shout again adn then shout louder and finally DS understands

Report
SueBaroo · 29/06/2007 19:32

me not understand. This Biddulph of which you speak... does he live in Narnia?

Report
fillyjonk · 29/06/2007 19:37

nearly

tasmania

OP posts:
Report
SueBaroo · 29/06/2007 19:41

He's been recommended to me. Sounds like I'd get better advice from dh's old sooty puppet. Is it really that inane?

Report
fillyjonk · 29/06/2007 19:43

oh probably not

it has lots on techniques

am worried about shyness thing though. he does seem to see shyness/cautiousness as evidence of kids not having their emotional needs met

OP posts:
Report
FioFio · 29/06/2007 19:43

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

mummypigoink · 29/06/2007 19:43

Noodlestroodle ~ my dds are like that too

Report
NotQuiteCockney · 29/06/2007 19:44

Surely shy/outgoing cautious/bold are continuums, with people falling in various positions.

Report
moondog · 29/06/2007 19:45

The point is that nonone needs to Fio.
Just say it to yourself.
Most of this stuff is staggeringly obvious, but written down prettily.
I say this as one who works in the field of child devpt.
Throw 'em away,turn the tv off and eat with your kids,read to them,play with them a bit and let them be.

That is basically all you need to know.

Report
meandmyflyingmachine · 29/06/2007 19:45

Trouble is, no child is problem-free. And every problem is traced back to some parental fault. But no parent is fault-free. You can't win. Larkin was right...

Report
fillyjonk · 29/06/2007 19:45

no nqc

in fact shyness is a myth, see p 68

OP posts:
Report
meandmyflyingmachine · 29/06/2007 19:47

Some people certainly do make a lot of money out of stating the bleeding obvious.

Report
FioFio · 29/06/2007 19:48

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

IsabelWatchingItRainInMacondo · 29/06/2007 19:48

Yes, he said that, and also that a good way to help children out of their shyness is to punish them if they refuse to say "hi"

Out of that, and other annoying things, I think his book "raising boys" is quite good, although more like informative theoretical reading that practical suggestions.

Report
jackie2kids · 29/06/2007 20:30

I hate that book too.

I must admit I lost patience with it when it got to the bit about all children should be raised in communities in rural settings.

Howay!!

Report
NotQuiteCockney · 29/06/2007 21:31

God, I already had an attitude against Biddulph, but this stuff certainly isn't helping.

I do think that How to Listen So Your Kids Will Talk, and Talk so they will listen isn't entirely obvious, and is really worth reading. For what it's worth.

Report

Don’t want to miss threads like this?

Weekly

Sign up to our weekly round up and get all the best threads sent straight to your inbox!

Log in to update your newsletter preferences.

You've subscribed!

pagwatch · 29/06/2007 21:40

oh dear
i went to see him talk about his book Raising Boys.
He was completely lovely and his talk was (should I whisper this) helpful. I especially liked all the stuff about boys struggling developmentally behind girls and their differences in a formal academic setting. I am quite happy to conceed that maybe I am a moron and he was stating the bleedin obvious but at a time when my eldest son was struggling and i was tired and upset about DS2's special needs it was a great help. The bit about engaging boys and helping them to express emotion was also great and it also helped me help my son who was holding on to a lot of upset and grief about his brother. I don't remember him giving a toss about whether boys know their colours or not but maybe my memory is faulty.
Eldest boy is 14 now and a fab boy who is great with his brother and a genuine help to me so predictable and inane maybe but it seems to have helped us.

Report
Hathor · 29/06/2007 21:43

Moondog speaks sense.

Report
IsabelWatchingItRainInMacondo · 30/06/2007 11:48

Pagwatch, I think you are NOT a moron, but somebody who had the wonderful oportunity to hear the words from the author's own mouth. Which obviously allows you to evaluate the man behind the message, therefore having a more rounded view of all of it.

The fact that his books have been so popular and that they have helped people means that he is not wrong. But as with everything in life, it may suit some and not others. I draw the line in the nursery stuff. He may be right but it is not in everybody's hands, due to their own particular personal circumstances, not to send their children to nursery. Although I have found the information on the differences between boys and girls very helpful.

Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.