Hi all,
I hope I'm in the right place for this - I'm normally a lurker on AIBU and chat but really need some help. Please forgive the length. Some of this is very hard for me to say.
So, I have DD(4), DS(2) and I'm 38+3 with DC3.
The event I'm about to describe happened today, but is the tip of the iceberg. We have had a lot of poor behaviour - answering back, defiance, cheekiness, stuff which I have been passing off as a 4yr old phase and trying my best to manage.
DD is in nursery for 3 hrs a day. Collected her at 3pm. She asked if she could go outside to play. I told her no, as today we would be tidying her room. It is an absolute tip, stuff, toys, puzzles, clothes everywhere. DP had a chat with her on Sunday and they agreed she would spend a little time every day doing it, which hasn't been done, so I thought we'd tackle it together.
Once I told her, she started to cry. When we got back to the house, she refused to get out of the car. I warned her that if she didn't get out, she wouldnt get a treat after dinner, which is often enough. She still refused so I just picked her up out of the car. She then stood at the front door crying. Once I had DS out and opened the front door, she refused to come in, so I kind of pushed her in. She stood in the hallway crying at me.
DS started to ask for a DVD, which I put on for him, thinking he would watch bits of it while Dd and I tidied. She stood at the living room door crying at me, I ignored her. Once the DVd was on, I said come on, let's go. She stood at the bottom of the stairs and refused to go up. So still trying to ignore her tantrum, I took her by the arm and started to lead her up the stairs. Three stairs up, she snatched her arm back, threw herself against the wall and refused to move. Now, I was losing my temper, and she got a smack on the bum and told to get up the stairs. She still refused, I ended up shouting at her and smacking her again. She turned round, right in my face, and screamed with all her might. By now my temper was completely lost, I screamed right back at her to get upstairs, and when she turned to go up she got smacked again. And this one was hard. Not that smacking is our default discipline that I find the first two acceptable or anything, but I feel particularly terrible about the last one.
So, I thought I would bite the bullet and talk about it. What's done is done, best I can do now is learn from it. I have some issues which mean I always second-guess my treatment of DD, which I can go into of anyone thinks it may be relevant. I phoned DP in tears after the event, and he feels that with the way she has been behaving for so long, its understandable that I snapped and he actually thinks he would have reacted the same way. He said to calm down then go talk to her, tell her how unacceptable her behaviour was, and that she is to stay in her room, tidying, until dinner is ready. I have done that, and although she was annoyed, she accepted it. It sounds like she isn't doing anything though, I think chances are she is just sitting on her bed.
What would you have done? how could I have diffused this from the start? What discipline techniques do/did you use on a wilful child of her age?
One thing I will say is that we stopped using the naughty step when she was 3. At that point it wasn't working. She would do something which we'd warn her for, and she'd just say 'step, yeah!' and take herself out there without repeating the behaviour. It was no punishment for her.
I've talked to her a lot about the baby coming, and genuinely don't believe it to be a factor, but willing to accept it could be. Willing to accept anything that anyone might have to say so, please, hit me with it.
Please or to access all these features
Please
or
to access all these features
For free parenting resources please check out the Early Years Alliance's Family Corner.
Parenting
4 year old defiance/behaviour
17 replies
OhBrotherWhereArtThou · 30/05/2012 16:25
OP posts:
Flicktheswitch ·
01/06/2012 14:40
This reply has been deleted
Message withdrawn at poster's request.
Please create an account
To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.