Mumsnet Moonwatch

Mumsnet Talk

"The country's most popular meeting point for parents" The Times
  Topics | Active | Search  
PhonePayplus A phone is for life, not just for Christmas
With mobile phones on top of many children’s wish lists this Christmas, PhonepayPlus is encouraging parents to be more phone-aware when it comes to the ongoing costs of a mobile phone.For information and tips visit: www.phonepayplus.org.uk/output/A-phone-is-for-life.aspx PhonePayplus

Recipe of the week

penguinmum's creamy fish pie: smoky, seasonal fish in a creamy white sauce with grated, rather than mashed, tatties on top - a meal of the highest comfort-food order.

MN Local

Please login or join Mumsnet first.

Follow mumsnet on...

TwitterFacebookYoutube


Mumsnet Talk


Start new thread within this topic | Watch this thread | Flip this thread |
Add a message
This is page 1 of 49 (This thread has 482 messages.) First | Previous | Next | Last Go to page

How do we feel that private school kids fill Russell Group Unis?.... Controversial alert.

(482 Posts)
Yet I am increasingly finding that most of the people I know who have chosen private have done so because their DC just couldn't cope either socially or keep up academically in the local state schools (or a mixture of both!)- so they're individually hand-held, spoon-fed and tutored in the private sector- then emerge ready to grab those limited places from perhaps more clever but marginally less 'graded up' state school kids?
Add message | Report | Contact poster By Mon 20-Jul-09 09:08:43
I've got / had three children at "good" universities and they like me and indeed my siblings all were private educated from 5. But we are all also fairly clever genetically, also had helpful parents at home and most of us also work incredibly hard. All those factors led to the reasonable academic results (my siblings went to Oxford and Cambridge).

Most children go to staet schools - about 93% and about 50% or 60% at the better universities are from state schools. The more interseting issue is that posh state schools and academic state schools and state schools in areas with high house prices "steal" universities places from the poor. Perhaps that's the biggest inequality.

The better univerisities try very hard to recruit from sink schools but they also need to ensure they have clever enough pupils. It's no use learning to read age 19. It's too late to make up for bad teaching then.

As for showing off about children most people realise it's how they are as people that counts, how they treat others and those sorts of things that really matter not whether they get As at A level. My elder daughter who was probably a very rare thing - a girl with dyslexia going through Haberdashers - she did so well because of her hard work (and got AAB which for her was really good results) and she's got the job she starts in September because of her personal efforts in large part and probably also because she's an eldest child and they tend to succeed the most. Some of those aspects you might feel is due to the child - the hard work etc and others random . Like most English people I would always tend not to mention what my children achieve and highlight their failures. It's how the English are made, a national characteristic not to show off and for us to look with disdain on those who do.

Someone noticed a picture of my island last week when I was away on business. I don't then say - wow look I iown a private island because I have worked so hard and am so brilliant - I would say - it has no house on it and they cost less than French cottages etc.
lilymaid - I am informed by DD that the green wellie brigade are now known as 'rahs'
Add message | Report | Contact poster By Wed 15-Jul-09 10:31:35
The point about children's results though is that they cannot be compared with each other, because they have not all had the same schooling, opportunities etc. So although it isn't actually 'bragging', it is a slight degree of oneupmanship in some cases (not all).

That's the whole point of this thread really. I am sure scienceteacher's child will get exemplary results, I think that is a foregone conclusion, because that is why people pay for education.

No doubt mine will too, as he is at a state GS where they ALL get excellent results. I wouldn't compare his or my other DCs results with those gained from a crap school though. There would be no comparison. The same grades achieved from a crap school would speak volumes.

Having said that, I don't really see anything wrong with shouting from the rooftops about one's DCs marvellous results on an anonymous forum, saves annoying everyone else at dinner parties, university open days etc.
Add message | Report | Contact poster By Sun 12-Jul-09 14:32:31
You are utterly shameless Rusty. I only got a 2:2 from Exeter (also back in the days of green wellies) but I am redeemed and can become shameless by publicising by DS1's 2.1 from a Russell Group university last year.
Add message | Report | Contact poster By Sun 12-Jul-09 14:27:09
Good on yer rustybear.

I love a good brag too grin

I couldn't wait to tell my friends and of course the rellies when dd got her AS and A2 results. It was great that they could share our pleasure and pride. The only person who I felt was slightly less than ecstatic was one friend whose dd at got very similar results from a private school - but then I think she was just a bit envy that our dd achieved just as well and we'd saved our money too!
Add message | Report | Contact poster By Sun 12-Jul-09 13:42:21
As long as he didn't get a first, your last post was fine, rusty grin hmm
Well, as someone who has 'publicised' her children's results on this very thread, you presumably mean me, violethill grin

I did try to disguise my boasting put DS's 2:1 from a Russell Group University (oops, there I go againblush) into context, in that he was a state school pupil who not only got in to a RG university, but encountered more state school pupils than private there, and proved successful in getting a good degree.

However, it was a pretty flimsy device & you've obviously seen through me; it was shameless appropriation of my child's achievements, probably due to the fact that my own 2:1 at Exeter was not from a Russell Group university. shock (Of course, the Russell Group didn't even exist when I graduated in 1977....)
Add message | Report | Contact poster By Sun 12-Jul-09 13:18:18
People post on MN for a variety of reasons, probably the main one being to debate a wide range of issues which are broadly connected to parenting. It's perfectly possible to be interested in the issues, rather than feeling the need to know details of the lives of some posters children. I do actually have personal contact with a small number of MNers, and we email eachother, so if I wanted to share personal infomation with them I'd use personal email.
And I don't think debating issues is a 'waste of time' as you put it, at all. MN is a public forum and open to all.
Add message | Report | Contact poster By Sun 12-Jul-09 13:15:38
Come back in August and you will see a bit of a bragfest here about examination successes.

This is an anonymous forum for the majority of members here, so posting examination results is not that much of a violation of privacy - no one knows who the DCs are either!

I think that this is a fine place to discuss results, given that it is frowned upon in the coffee morning circuit.

I am quite amazed by your attitude, Violet. I really don't get it at all. I think it is sad that you can't share the celebration with mums who have supported their DCs through the years and nagged encouraged them to do their very best (whatever the result).

I am also dismayed that you feel the need to look down on those who have different values to you, or who express their emotions more openly.
Add message | Report | Contact poster By Sun 12-Jul-09 13:10:21
MN may be anonymous but there are real people behind most postings. Some people may be hairy-handed truckers or trolls but if someone has been posting consistent information for several years about their DC then I take them at face value.
If you are not interested in their lives then why on earth are you wasting time posting here?
This is page 1 of 49 (This thread has 482 messages.) First | Previous | Next | Last Go to page
Add your message here
Message
Nickname:
Password:
To post a message you need a valid mumsnet nickname and password. If you have forgotten your nickname, click here for a reminder. If you are not yet a member of mumsnet, you can join here.

Emphasis: To bold a word, surround it with asterisks, so *hello* will display hello. For underline use _ , so _hello_ gives hello. For italics use ^, so ^hello^ gives hello. To strike out a word, surround it with two hyphens either side, so --dog-- gives dog

Links and smileys: To insert a smiley face,  , type [smile] or :)
For a big grin,  , type [grin] or :o
For a wink,  , type [wink]
For a shocked face,  , type [shock]
For an angry face,  , type [angry]
For an embarrassed face,  , type [blush]
For a sad face,  , type [sad] or :(
For an envious face,  , type [envy]
For a sceptical face,  , type [hmm]
For a no comment face,  , type [biscuit]

Links The simplest way to insert a link is to enter the link itself, surrounded by [[ and ]]. So if you type [[www.mumsnet.com]], the link will display as http://www.mumsnet.com. If you want your link to display text other than the web address itself, leave a space after the address then add the text before the ]]. So "Look at [[www.mumsnet.com this page]]", would display "Look at this page".
Shortcuts