I know it's weird but....

[milly987]

I'm not pg, or planning to be anytime soon, but I would love these names for a daughter - I wish that it would ever be possible!!

I know they are herbs/spices, but if Cicily, Saffron, Jasmine, Poppy, Rosemary etc are ok shouldn't these be?!

Tarragon
Cinnamon
Anise
Sage
Sorrel

Are they completely unnacceptable?

[said]

Cinnamon is great. Think you coudl get away with Anise and Sorrel as well. Will be thinking of more now...

[redllamayellowllama]

I think Sorrel is actually quite nice and may even be a legitimate name! Sage is more of a boy's name - my male is a Sage.

The other three - completely unacceptable.

[llareggub]

I know a few Sorrels.

[redllamayellowllama]

My male cousin, that is.

[Katy86]

i know a sorrell lovely

[BessieBoots]

Sage is great, but risky if he turns out to be unwise...

[said]

I did come across a little girl called Chilli once. But that was in Brighton...

[GrimmaTheNome]

There's a minor character called Coriander on the Archers, isn't there?

Glad you didn't suggest Chive, Parsley or Cumin.

[milly987]

@ Grimmathenome

I'm not suggesting them because they are herbs and spices!!! I just really wish that Tarragon and Cinnamon were real names, because I think they are really pretty!

Glad Sage and Sorell don't appear too odd.

I think if Tarragon and Cinnamon were just made up words and not a herb or a spice people wouldn't react as strangely when I told them!!

Tarragon. She could always change it if she hated it.

The other thing is I would never want two daughters called Tarragon and Cinnamon - that would just be cruel.

[Bumnoise]

I know an Anise she is part French and I think it's much more common there.

[milly987]

also, LOL @ BessieBoots!!!

[DorotheaPlenticlew]

I know a Cinnamon in RL. She lives up to it, though -- you'd have to. It's one of those names that could backfire if you had a very shy, retiring child who hated being different ...

[MamaLazarou]

Cinnamon was the name of a character in the Mission Impossible TV series. She was v v glam (but had pooey 70s teeth).

[Cortina]

I know a Barley and a Saige (an Indian name).

[milly987]

Both me and DP have red hair, so Cinnamon could run the risk of teasing as a result I guess.

Good to know there are some RL people with these names..makes me feel less freaky for liking them!

All are staying on my shortlist

[mathanxiety]

I know one Annese, but not Anise. And a 9 year old Sage (a girl).

Cinnamon is a little red light, imo. Sorrel makes me thin of ponies. Tarragon, no, not a name.

[GetOrfMoiLand]

Sorrel is a lovely name.

Anise - yes, that would make a lovely name as well.

Tarragon and Cinnamon are silly ideas, sorry.

Sylvester Stallone called his son Sage. For that reason alone I would say no.

If you like Spicey names what about Cassia? It is a spice similar to cinnamon.

Also, Nigella. It is a black spice (called Kalonji in Indian supermarkets).

And Saffron.

[GetOrfMoiLand]

Sorry just saw you has Saffron in the OP.

[CinderellaRach]

This is a wind-up

[milly987]

Hi CinderellaRach - it's not a wind up.

I am 26, live in a large town up North, am a step-mum to 2 gorgeous kids - both of whom have normal but lovely names.

I am an avid reader of baby name posts (come into contact with a lot of mothers in my work and general life so have always been interested in what people name their kids) and have always had a 'shortlist', ever since I was a kid. Normally influenced by books/tv programmes etc.

I really do like the names Cinammon and Tarragon. As I said, not both together, but just a small musing on how lovely I think it would be if you could name your kids anything (within reason) that you thought was pretty.

Nothing inflamatory there, surely? I'm not suggesting mandatory herb/spice names for all kids. I'm not slating anyone else's choices. Just asking for some MN feedback.

Geez.

Getorfmoiland - Cassia is very pretty, but a bit too close to my own name sadly to come across as anything but ego!! Not too keen on Nigella, I know it's a silly thing to say but it's too close to Nigel. Which is a horrible name IMO.

Saffron is pretty, but just quite common - well, not unusual I guess I mean.

If Tarragon wasn't a herb, and you'd never heard the word before - would it still be silly??

[MaggieSilver]

Sorrel is nice. I don't like the rest.

What about Bay?

[MaggieSilver]

Milly, when I was pregnant I remembering thinking the names Alpine and Milano would be nice.

[GoldenSnitch]

Sorrel is a lovely name. I know a Sorrel

Anise is nice

Sage - not sure

Tarragon and Cinnamon are just plain daft, sorry.

[MaggieSilver]

Anise is just dangerously close to anus in my opinion.

[milly987]

@MaggieSilver

Bay is a pub near my house, haha!

I think it's nice for a boy, not particularly feminine IMO. Didn't Kirstie Allsop call her son that?