Samuel and Daniel ... too rhyme-y? (Even though full names aren't / won't be used)

(33 Posts)
KatharineClover Sat 28-Jun-14 07:52:12

Hi everyone,
We have DS1 called Samuel (but known as Sammy or Sam) and due DS2 in September. The only name both DH and I both agree on and love is Daniel, (to be known as Dan or Danny). I was really happy with the choice (but we won't tell anyone irl until after the baby us here) but there is a bit of me that is having a wobble and is worried about the fact that 'Samuel and Daniel' almost rhyme ... even though it will be quite rare that I would say both names in full together.
Does it sound daft to you?
Other names we liked were Benjamin, but as surname begins with a T I didn't want him known as 'Ben T' at school. Also don't want a similar first initial to us (no S, L or J) and we want a traditional name that shortens. DH has a big family a lot of names are already taken.
Thanks for your thoughts x

VivaLeBeaver Sat 28-Jun-14 07:52:56

Sounds daft, sorry. Really daft.

Mumof3xox Sat 28-Jun-14 07:53:39

I think it's fine tbh!

BlueStarsAtNight Sat 28-Jun-14 08:07:39

Sorry but I do think it sounds silly! I also think Sam and Dan or Sammy and Danny are too rhymey aswell tbh!

I love Daniel but wouldn't use it myself as my DS's name sounds similar to Sam.

Good call on avoiding Ben T too.

How about something like:

Michael
Louis
William
Robert
Matthew
Alexander

SavoyCabbage Sat 28-Jun-14 08:08:28

I was going to say yes, all good as long as you don't have Sam and Dan or Sammy and Danny as I think they are more samey than the long versions.

AChildminder88 Sat 28-Jun-14 08:11:39

My OH and his brother are Sam and Dan I don't think it sounds daft at all!!!

SanityClause Sat 28-Jun-14 08:14:23

They are lovely names.

What does it matter if they are a bit rhyme-y? For the most part, people will know them separately, anyway, not as "Sam and Dan".

Only problem is, if you have another child (and I didn't want three, either, but I have three!) will it be weird if their name is quite different?

nooka Sat 28-Jun-14 08:14:58

Sorry but I agree with everyone else they are just too similar, whether you use the long forms or the short (Sammy/Danny; Sam/Dan) I do think it sounds overly matchy matchy.

As you like traditional names how about Andrew/Andy, Christopher/Kit, Robert/Rob, Richard/Ritchie, Edward/Ed, Michael/Mike, Nicholas/Nick?

Notso Sat 28-Jun-14 08:19:06

I know brothers called Dan(iel) and Sam(uel) One was in DD's class and one in DS1's class. It has never occurred to me that their names sound similar in the 9 years I have known them.

AChildminder88 Sat 28-Jun-14 08:38:56

I agree notso once you know the person you don't even hear the name, if you know what I mean...?!

Bowlersarm Sat 28-Jun-14 08:41:53

I think they are far too close. Sorry.

Notso Sat 28-Jun-14 09:01:06

Exactly AChildminder88 sometimes I think you can over analyse names a bit. I was worried one of our choices for DS3's name and our surname together sounded a bit like Slytherin when I was pregnant hmm I had forgotten about it until now.

Marcipex Sat 28-Jun-14 11:50:00

I think it's fine.

Melons79 Sat 28-Jun-14 11:54:25

Doesn't Ed Milliband have a Samuel and Daniel?

I don't see a problem.

Nereida Sat 28-Jun-14 17:55:29

I think it's fine. I actually think they're quite nice together.

Other suggestions:

Edward (Ed/Eddie)
Frederick (Fred/Freddie)
Nicholas (Nick/Nicky/Nico)
Oliver (Olly/Ollie)
Thomas (Tom/Tommy)
William (Will/Billy)
Zachary (Zac/Zach)

Harrin Sat 28-Jun-14 20:54:01

My partner is a Ben T and said he got the jokes all the time at school, so I'd avoid that too

KatharineClover Sun 29-Jun-14 19:53:04

Thanks for your thoughts everyone - looks like an even split between daft/fine which makes the choice hard!
I also like Teddy (have done since a teen reading Little Women) but DS has a comforter named teddy so that would be confusing.
It was a lot easier choosing DS's name!

flowerpowers Sun 29-Jun-14 22:24:14

Too similar, as is Sam/my and Dan/ny imo. I'd choose different vowels, like Samuel and William or Samuel and Nathan.

DramaAlpaca Sun 29-Jun-14 22:33:42

I don't see the problem at all.

Samuel & Daniel are fine together.

madboob Sun 29-Jun-14 22:36:58

I think they sound fine, but for alternatives I like Joseph (Joe), Oliver (Ollie), Edward (Eddie) & William (Billy).smile

ScrambledEggAndToast Sun 29-Jun-14 22:41:36

A bit silly tbh. A woman I used to know had two boys called Theo and Leo which I always thought sounded a bit daft.

I know of brothers called Albert and Herbert (long deceased). So in comparison Samuel and Daniel are fine. Go for it.

ChickenFajitasAndNachos Tue 01-Jul-14 16:47:05

They are bit rhymey but both lovely names.

squoosh Tue 01-Jul-14 16:54:31

I think they sound silly together.

Petitgrain Tue 01-Jul-14 16:59:11

I think they sound too similar. Teddy's great though!

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now